The difference in one table
| Franna (pick and carry) | Slewing mobile crane | |
|---|---|---|
| How it lifts | Lifts with the boom over the front and steers by bending in the middle | Sets up in one spot and turns the boom up to 360 degrees |
| Moving with the load | Can carry the load on the hook at walking pace | Lifts from a fixed set-up, then packs up to move |
| Outriggers | Not needed for pick and carry work | Needed, with room and firm ground for the pads |
| Set-up time | Quick, it drives in and lifts | Longer, it needs to set up and level |
| Ground | Firm, level ground. Side slopes cut its capacity | Firm ground under each outrigger pad |
| Best for | Tight sites, short moves, unloading trucks, shifting loads around a site | Long reach over houses and buildings, high lifts from one spot |
Safe Work Australia calls cranes like the Franna non-slewing mobile cranes. Their rated capacity assumes firm, level ground, and a side slope of only 2 to 3 degrees can drastically affect stability, which is why a good operator travels up or down a slope rather than across it.
Which crane suits which job
| Job | Often suits | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Shipping container off a truck onto a slab or sleepers | Franna | It can lift the container off and carry it into place on the hook |
| Machinery shifted around a factory or yard | Franna | It lifts and walks the machine to its new spot without setting up again |
| Trusses or steel lifted onto a frame | Either, depends on the reach | A Franna suits when it can get close. A long reach over the building may need a slewing crane |
| Spa or pool over a fence or shed with a short reach | Franna | Quick set-up and it can move with the load |
| Pool over a two storey house into a deep backyard | Often a slewing crane | The long reach is the deciding factor |
| Tiny home or cabin off a truck onto footings near the street | Franna | It can lift and place it in one move |
| Boat in or out of a shed, onto a trailer or stand | Franna | It lifts the boat and carries it into position |
Your site, and what we bring
| Your site | What we bring |
|---|---|
| Tight driveway, narrow side access or a small site | Our 12t Franna, which drives in and lifts without outriggers |
| Heavier load or a longer reach | Our 25t Franna |
| Power lines near the street or the lift | Electrical spotting arranged where it's needed |
| Crane or truck has to use the road or footpath | Local council permits coordinated and traffic management facilitated |
| Load needs moving from somewhere else | Heavy haulage transport arranged |
| Load needs slinging, guiding or a lift plan | Riggers and dogmen supplied when the job needs them |
| Very long reach over a building | We'll tell you straight if it needs a crane we don't run |
We only run Franna cranes, and we'll tell you straight
Our fleet is a 12 tonne and a 25 tonne Franna, and they handle a wide range of residential, building and machinery lifts. If your job needs a long reach that a pick and carry crane can't do safely, we'll tell you when we quote, before you book. See Franna crane hire or read what a Franna crane is.
Sources
- Safe Work Australia, General guide for cranes: mobile cranes
- WorkSafe Victoria, Prevent pick and carry cranes from overturning
This guide is general information to help you plan a lift. Permit names, fees and timeframes can change, so check the council page before you apply. For your job, call us on 0414 649 934.